manmountain last edited by
Sorry, but although I can detect the difference in taste between cheap whiskey and expensive whiskey, they're just different, not better or worse to me. I'm in for the high, not the taste, as long as it's not gagging bad. So I've explored the bottom shelf stuff and drink 75 South, the Albertson's/Von's store brand. Fairly smooth, gets 'meh reviews, minimal to no hangover, and, the key is it's $13.00USD for two quarts (not a typo).
I'll drink the high end stuff at your house if you offer me some; if you visit my house it'll be 75 South, all you want to drink
Scole last edited by Scole
Lagavulin 16 y/o is something special if you like smokey/peaty single malts.
toby last edited by
Indeed. Lagavulin is the distillery that hooked me into the Islay single malts. My Scotch Whisky palate had previously been rather uneducated and limited to the bottles of Glenlivet and Glenfiddich my Bro would gift me for special occasions and such cuz I was a "regular dirtbag" and the cost of a bottle of Scotch likely equated to food for a week. Or more. Hence, the afflicted amongst us forewent such extravagances in favor of more time on the rocks. Pun intended. Exploration of the extremes of smoky peat monsters ultimately led me to Laphroaig's 10 yr. Cask Strength, a.k.a. "Red Stripe". I've since lost my taste for Islay's, and Scotch, in general, preferring the subtleties of American Bourbon Whiskeys. Meanwhile, my wife has developed such so the Laphroaig Triple Wood she gifted me for my last birthday will likely linger until she gets around to crackin' it. Smart woman.
Scole last edited by
I did a tour around Scotland a couple of years ago. We visited a number of distilleries. Of everything I tried the Lagavulin was my favorite, although there are many good choices.
Yeah, from memory, the Lagavulin is probably a nice middle ground, balanced Islay. Laphroaig is pretty "medicinal", with a distinct iodine nose from the kelp and seaweed aromas absorbed from the surrounding air. Wife was into rum when we met. Now she's a smoky peat monster gal. Intriguing how tastes can change so dramatically.
Did you tour Caol Ila, Ardbeg, and Bowmore?
I've had the Caol Ila 12yr. and 18yr. and recall it was "okay" but nothing special. Ardbeg 10yr. was more "unique" in flavor but also gave me one heck of a headache. Mayhaps my constitution be too weak fer' non-chill filtered esters and phenols...
I loathe the Bowmore and unquestionably * the* worst Scotch of any distillery I ever tasted. Legends in their own minds, they are as well, and priced accordingly. Every guest that ever sampled that Bowmore 17 yr. old never asked for a second dram. It was undrinkable in my opinion so lingered on my shelf for many, many years. Truly in a "class by itself". I had occasion to vent about it to one of their reps who totally disagreed with my description of its profile and he asserted I must have "somehow gotten a contaminated bottle". Offered to replace it but actions failed to follow verbiage so my opinion of Bowmore remains unchanged.
Speaking of Diageo, how many years back do you go with Lagavulin? Have you noticed a flavor profile change post Chinese ownership days ? Talisker, author Robert Louis Stevenson's preferred poison, used to be one of my all time favorite "go to" single malts as well. Then reasonably priced at about $45/bottle. Post 2008 depression that doubled. The few times I've sampled it since I've been disappointed. Don't know if because my taste buds changed over the years or because ensuing economic realities precipitated a sell out?
Scole last edited by Scole
I was in Scotland two years ago. The 16y/o Lavagulin was the Peatiest/ Smokiest whiskey that I sampled. I don't know about ownership, but if it was truly 18 y/o, it predated change of ownership. Angus Thuermer (Anguish on ST) has roots on the isle of Sky, and Talisker frequently popped up on our various rambles amongst the hills, but to each their own. I really prefer Tequila or Rum to whiskey.
David Harris last edited by
When I first sampled Lagavulin (almost 40 years ago), it retailed for $24 a bottle in Vancouver, where I was living. I loved it, and it, along with Ardbeg, remained my favorites.
But over the years, my desire for spirits of any kind gradually waned, although I certainly enjoyed a glass of good Whiskey (or Tequila) from time to time. That shrinking desire for Lagavulin should have been a good thing, because the price of good single malt took off into the stratosphere. Unfortunately it was replaced by a desire for the Barolos and Barbarescos of Italy's Piedmont. Ouch!
Which brings me to yesterday, when I parked in the lot of a local liquor store here in my new hometown of Powell River, BC, which, despite being only 70 miles from Vancouver in distance, is six hours away in time. (Two ferries required to get here.) It's a peaceful place, far removed from the crime and politics of most of the US and Canada, and, as usual, I didn't bother closing the car window.
In the store I got the first of two surprises. Perusing the single malt selection I found Lagavulin 16, my old favorite -- at $124 a bottle! I knew it had gone up over the years, but damn...
Second surprise came when I returned to my car, and noticed a sheet of white paper on the passenger seat. Had someone bumped the car? Or was unhappy with the way it was parked?
Neither. But the two words written on the paper made clear was that someone had noticed my US (Washington) plates, and, either in sympathy or anger, had left me this...
(The car is actually my wife's and since she's still working in the US, she has kept the US plates.)
Whisky Frisky A-Go-Go, circa 2018?
Clyde Mays Straight Bourbon Whiskey. One of my mid shelf favorites! Indeed.
Quite the international round up of suspects. A couple Irish, Single Malt Scotch, and American Bourbons. Ooh, la, la!! Nice whisk(e)y sampling here. Indeed.
Blanton's Single Barrel. Winner, winner, chicken dinner! I also spy, with my little eye, a couple Islays in the lurking...
Belvenie Caribbean Cask! Not one of my favorites since I am not a rum person. Wife likes it just fine and dandy.
Although Balvenie was one of the early Scotch distillery's to begin double wooding their single malts, my all time favorite Balvenie, as well as single malts overall is the Balvenie 15yr. Single Cask. Yep. Select held back before the second cask double finish Hard to find.
Double Oaked Woodford Reserve. Extra oakey bourbon. Indeed.
Old Forester Statesman
Old Forester Statesman. A favorite of favorites. I suspect Blanton's, and several other high end bourbons will have a hard time standing up to a blind head to head tastey test with this one! Toby recommended.
Continuously produced prohibition style. Fer' medicinal purposes. Oohh, la, la!!